This profile is from a federated server and may be incomplete. View on remote instance

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

Whatever you prefer calling occupied territories, I don't consider a subject for dictatorship. Dictatorship is something I consider an internal state of the country, so no other territories should affect it. An aggression on neighbouring territories can be a result of dictatorship but never a reason for it. So whatever is going on with "occupied" territories is not a subject for this discussion for me.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

have been under Israeli Military Control since 1967.

You didn't see the comment tree? It's about Netanyahu. Are you going to pretend he is responsible for all of that?

If you ignore all of that

When we're talking about whether or not some person is a dictator - yes, its irrelevant. Dictatorship is about having a power against the will of too many citizens, also silencing them, jailing them, killing them etc.

If you consider a democracy

Don't need that. There are not 2 types of government. It may not be a democracy, but it's similarly difficult to qualify as a dictatorship.

Palestinian citizens are about 20% of Israeli population. Black people are about 14% of the US population. Both of them hold legal citizenships and rights but often face disparities. Does that make the US an apartheid by your logic?

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

As I said before, there is no line. You can't assume some regime fell into the other side after a short time. These things develop for years. Or could you try to classify the US regime? Surely it's not a democracy when people can only choose between 2.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

Not helping. Apartheid or not, my criteria is how well government cares about its citizens, and that term ignores that. Political gain or not, my stance is that it started with October 7th attack, which was not prepared by current Israeli government, therefore it's correct to blame another party. Protesters doing their thing is good for everyone, we should start worrying when they are unable to do that anymore due to oppressive laws, police raids etc.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

You're changing the subject by trying to describe it with unsuitable words. Your actual thought is that it's bad and should be changed, but you first tried calling it a dictatorship, then autocracy. People of Israel aren't living in such conditions yet. Better just get back to "doing war is bad" stance.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

You don't need to ask me how I prefer calling a regime in a country in order to make it look bad. I don't have such preferences. There are people suffering in any country including yours, and their lives could get better with new elections. This is not an extraordinary situation.

I don't need to invent words for Israel. I would call it bad when I see it does terrible things to its own people. This is not a case for now and from what I know, there is no imminent conflict/crisis between government and citizens. That's aside from the war conflict/intervention situation of course. I would also appreciate hamas if they did a better job at governing gaza, but instead they bombed it with inaccurate missiles as a side effect of trying to harm Israel. This is a huge difference - I call the Palestinian regime bad because of that, and suggest they could manage it much better. When compared to Israel, I don't see much obvious room for improvement (I don't see a lot of Israeli people suffering) and thus I can't call it bad.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

You're acting ignorant with the last sentence. There is no line between democracies and dictatorships. There is a long way until we could call Israel a dictatorship. When they will marsh the streets after some next elections get cancelled (unconstitutionally), and huge numbers get arrested, then we'll talk.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

I hear Putin is a dictator and there are tons of evidence. I hear Xi is a dictator and there are tons of evidence. The evidence you gave (an article with words from one person) is laughable at best, sorry. Israeli people seem to live just fine under Netanyahu. Also it doesn't seem probable that he would attack Gaza if the October 7 attack didn't happen (and people are having a hard time trying to prove that he somehow made it possible). Same with Lebanon.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

I don't think we have the same understanding of dictatorship. Dictatorship can't be hidden to the point of being only apparent to special people. It should be obvious to everyone and especially citizens affected (oppressed) by it. So far I'm not seeing any evidence of that.

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

One person? That's not an opposition. Where is the opposition movement? Where are oppressed citizens?

rdri , to World News in Israel ready for ‘all-out war’ in Lebanon

This seems inconsistent with previous overwhelming thought that Israel wants to kill Palestine completely. Killing that many people that fast (in a course of just a few months) would not let it last for too long in the end.

Also, is there evidence of Israel being a dictatorship? Is there an opposition that is being threatened or killed or something?

rdri , to memes in Ah yes, organization.

It slows down the browser though. I switched to sidebery.

rdri , to World News in Israeli military rescues four hostages alive from Gaza, including Noa Argamani

entirely expected

I could say the same about the ground operation.

They've never had as much international support as they do now.

Not sure if that really helps, also the price was too high. I'm fact, I really doubt they had that scenario in mind.

rdri , (edited ) to World News in Israeli military rescues four hostages alive from Gaza, including Noa Argamani

Everything hamas did was useless for Palestinians. Israel isn't stopping because they have the ability. Hamas doesn't, they won't win in a military fight and hostages are useless for them. They could start doing something proper like releasing hostages (woyild decrease support for Israel hugely) but they won't because they think it would help them survive (not even Palestinians).

Hamas had a chance to increase its abilities over time, but instead they chose to spend resources on useless attacks.

rdri , to World News in Israeli military rescues four hostages alive from Gaza, including Noa Argamani

Trying my best as a non-native. Feel free to hate my way of speaking.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • kbinchat
  • All magazines