A Slint fanboy from Berlin.

This profile is from a federated server and may be incomplete. View on remote instance

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

The blocking certain countries is a US legal thing. It effects any forge in the US and probably in more areas close to the US. As soon as a forge gets big enough to show up on the radar of government orge they will need to do similar blocking.

You can not really blame github for that part.

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

The biggest factor to me is developer attention. I had a project on gitlab and pushed a README.md with a link to the gitlab instance into github. I got about 10 times more reactions from github, incl. PRs (where the person had grabbed the code from gitlab and did a PR on github anyway) -- even in this setup. Mirroring a project to github tilts that even further.

Not being present on github means a lot less users and contributors. As long as that stays this way there is no way around github.

I hope federated forges can move some attention away from github, making other forges more visible... but I am not too optimistic :-(

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

That unfortunately requires setting up email... I have not bothered doing so on my boxes in a very long time.

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

I never said that you can not run a project elsewhere, my point is that you will get way more interaction on github.

Try pushing your project to github and compare the interactions you get from both forges.

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

Github login does not help much... devs are on github, not on random forgjo instances. That's where they see your project. Github is also where they put their fork of your project when they play with it. They will write comments using github markdown and won't care whether that renders correctly or not in your forge.

And it is where they will report issues and open a PR. It is annoying, but it is how it is. When you ask them to open the PR elsewhere they complain sinde they need to set up an account there and copy ssh key and similar things. You need a very dedicated contributor to go through with all that.... especially if it is just a few lines of drive-by fixes.

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

Rustfmt is not very configurable. That is a wonderful thing: People don't waste time on discussing different formatting options and every bit of rust code looks pretty identical.

hunger ,
@hunger@programming.dev avatar

Why would they need to share ssh keys? Ssh will happily accept dozens of allowed keys.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • kbinchat
  • All magazines