GeriatricGardener ,
@GeriatricGardener@kolektiva.social avatar

“Do you condemn Hamas?: The question we have to ask ourselves is not whether we condemn Hamas, but whether we condemn a settler colonial regime that makes armed struggle necessary for survival.”

by James Ray in Mondoweiss @mondoweiss

@palestine @israel

“Like them [Hamas] or not, the efforts they have waged and continue to wage have made more of a material impact toward the liberation of Palestine than anything any of us in the West will ever make. They are taking on the brutal violence of colonial power and waging a campaign of armed struggle that has, at the current moment, with coordination with other resistance factions, made the Zionist colony more of a pariah than it has ever been on a global stage and shattered the image of military invincibility and overall stability it has spent decades cultivating. Countless years of struggle have culminated in this flashpoint.”

https://mondoweiss.net/2024/06/do-you-condemn-hamas/?ml_recipient=123391519249926016&ml_link=123391510330738497&utm_source=newsletter&utm_medium=email&utm_term=2024-06-06&utm_campaign=Daily+Headlines+RSS+Automation

Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar

@GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel in a word no. They're the only thing standing between the Israeli death machine & the innocent peoples of Palestine

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@GeriatricGardener all terrorist organizations must be condemned in a moral society. there is no justification for terrorism. @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

GeriatricGardener OP ,
@GeriatricGardener@kolektiva.social avatar

@zephry @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

Are those who use violence to resist/ defeat colonial oppression terrorists?

Is there no justification for the actions of these ⤵️ people?

ANC/ Mandela in S Africa
Toussaint in Haiti
IRA in Northern Ireland
PLO/ Arafat
Mugabe in Zimbabwe

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

it depends on how you define terrorist. anyone who murders and rapes as a means to an end is a terrorist regardless of how just they believe their cause might be.

nathaliaassaad ,
@nathaliaassaad@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

@zefry: I guess the IDF is the perfect example of a terrorist in that case, per your description. Thank you!

Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel one man's terrorist, is another Man's freedom fighter
If not for freedom fighters ALL oppressed people would still be in chains.
The only language oppressor's know is violence.

Sometimes good people have to do bad things to achieve freedom

Would you sit back while your family was killed? Your community destroyed? Your country invaded & stolen?

I know I wouldn't.

If you're honest, neither would you.

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel "Would you sit back while your family was killed? Your community destroyed? Your country invaded & stolen? " if you omit the last word, this is exactly what hamas did on oct 7th.

Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel you forget who invaded who, Israelis Zionists invaded Palestine in 1946, warred against the native inhabitants, you may have heard of it the
they slaughtered innocent civilians, men, women, children, drove the rest out of "israel" they've been doing it ever since.
Israel is not a state it's an invading, occupying terrorist army. The only state is Palestine, israel is a zionist colonial idea. Who's end is fast approaching.

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@Sine_Nomine @zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

I think @zephry 's knowledge of the middle East only goes back as far as 7th October 2023

Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar

@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel
sadly yes, if only the truth was more widely known This is changing, the western media is losing the electronic intifada, alternative outlets are winning through, the truth is coming out

In every poll of attitudes to israel the youth; under 35; are overwhelming against israel in all actions they take

This demographic will ensure the future is Palestinian, not Israeli. The Zionist settler movement is ending 🙏

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel if you want to go as far back as possible in the recorded history of that area, jews would be considered indigenous.

jeremy_pm ,
@jeremy_pm@mastodon.nz avatar

@zephry

How far back are we going?
After all, humanity is indigenous to Africa.

@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

DropBear ,
@DropBear@theblower.au avatar

Interesting question @jeremy_pm
The region being a route from Africa to Europe, there's evidence of modern humans in the area 120,000 years ago. Judaism hasn't existed that long.

Before that, there were other hominids. The earliest remains are estimated to be 1.5 million years old.

As to "recorded history". Even their own mythology tells against the Jewish. Chapter 15 of Genesis/Bereshit lists peoples who were displaced to establish the Jewish Kingdoms. So Jews weren't "first". There may be "indigenous" jews, but there are also indigenous Moslems and Christians.

The Zionist invasion began in the 19th century @Sine_Nomine
Its foundations can be traced to the British Empire, around 1840.
@zephry @Captain_Jack_Sparrow









@GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@DropBear @jeremy_pm @Sine_Nomine @Captain_Jack_Sparrow @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel 'modern humans' and 'hominids' are not indigenous ethnic groups. neither are moslems or christians.

jeremy_pm ,
@jeremy_pm@mastodon.nz avatar

@zephry

So you support USA and Canada being returned to the indigenous peoples of America? After all, the colonisation and ethnic cleansing of both countries happened far more recently than 2-3,000 years ago.

@DropBear @Sine_Nomine @Captain_Jack_Sparrow @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

DropBear ,
@DropBear@theblower.au avatar

You're using the Israeli Zionist hasbara definition of "indigenous", I see @zephry
As their own mythology affirms, Jews took the lands from other peoples. They're thus colonisers.

For centuries, Arabs, Christians and Jews shared Palestine. Then the Zionists started arriving. To paraphrase article 12 of the Jerusalem Declaration:
all should be allowed to live together in peace in the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea
as equals
http://jerusalemdeclaration.org/









@jeremy_pm @Sine_Nomine
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@jeremy_pm @Captain_Jack_Sparrow @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel i think the term indigenous when applied to humans today means specific ethnic groups.

DropBear ,
@DropBear@theblower.au avatar

Actually, there is no generally accepted definition of "indigenous" @zephry
That's why Israeli Zionists use the term for hasbara. They can pretend that it means whatever is convenient to their argument.









@jeremy_pm @Captain_Jack_Sparrow @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @jeremy_pm @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

You do realise Palestinians are Semitic, right?

Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar
Sine_Nomine ,
@Sine_Nomine@mstdn.social avatar

@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @zephry @jeremy_pm @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel apparently the wrong kind of semetic, the one's Zionists can be antisemitic to.

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar
Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @Sine_Nomine @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

No, so now there are 40,000 more reasons why the people of Gaza want revenge against Israeli warcrimes. If you were a civilian in Gaza, you'd be the same.

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

Thi is a terorist militia.

...testimonies from inmates revealed horrifying conditions. For most of the time, they were kept in a state of sensory deprivation, made to wear blacked-out goggles, except for when being tortured. In one case that later came to court, a Lebanese captive had been sodomised with a baton by “Major George”,

https://www.middleeasteye.net/big-story/israel-torture-chambers-message-directed-us-palestinians

zephry ,
@zephry@mindly.social avatar

@Captain_Jack_Sparrow @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel if this report is true it would be considered torture not terrorism.

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

Are you saying torture is not a form of terrorism?

Especially when it's used against civilians.

Captain_Jack_Sparrow ,
@Captain_Jack_Sparrow@mastodon.world avatar

@zephry @GeriatricGardener @mondoweiss @palestine @israel

Do you condemn Israeli warcrimes against Palestinians?

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • [email protected]
  • kbinchat
  • All magazines