Gutek8134 ,
@Gutek8134@lemmy.world avatar

Looks like something from Monty Python and Holy Grail

Emperor ,
@Emperor@feddit.uk avatar

Well it was filmed in the Scottish Lowlands not a million miles away (48 miles from Doune Castle).

tjsauce ,

Looks weird, but if they added a 3rd aesthetic, like Japanese wooden housing, or Russian brutalism, then we'd be talking.

sharkfucker420 ,
@sharkfucker420@lemmy.ml avatar
waz ,

Bit of goosewing grey and it’s good to go.

Emperor , (edited )
@Emperor@feddit.uk avatar

I remember when this hit the news and do hope it's been redone since.

edit: no updates on the Scottish Castle Association since 2012 and TripAdvisor photos show it unchanged other than some weathering.

edit2: Here is the episode of The Restoration Man that focused on the tower and it explains the planning process that led to this monstrosity.

vext01 ,
@vext01@lemmy.sdf.org avatar

Is that a news crew huddling at the foot of it?

Emperor , (edited )
@Emperor@feddit.uk avatar

It was featured in S1E4 of The Restoration Man, so I presume George Clarke is somewhere in that picture.

edit: and they return to it in S2E5 which is on YouTube.

morphballganon ,

Should have painted it to match

ramenshaman ,

A natural wood finish would have looked pretty good

cerement ,
@cerement@slrpnk.net avatar

only plus I can see is that the renovation is visibly distinguishable – they’re not trying to pass it off as a “restoration” …

thanks_shakey_snake ,

Another comment ITT claims that that's exactly why they did it this way-- Regulations say it must have that property.

Tiltinyall ,

I was just thinking you couldn't get an A/C installer anywhere near the property without the modern add-on.

moreeni ,

Average looking house in Ukraine. Khrushchovka that itself doesn't look too good is ruined by the fact that each flat was renovated with 0 attention to how the other ones look. There are usually some white walls, some gray, some are still orange form the bricks, some balconies have windows, some don't.

vinceman ,

Everytime I start to really disagree with things like heritage zoning I see something like this.

Successful_Try543 ,

Why on earth white plastic windows and baby blue paint?

freebee ,

Budgeting? White PVC windows are cheapest, you pay extra for colors.

Successful_Try543 ,

I know.

However, if you own a cultural heritage building, the c.h. office has a lot of saying about each and every modification done, especially on the outside, so I doubt it's due to financial issues.

Emperor ,
@Emperor@feddit.uk avatar

This mess is because the planning authorities rejected more subtle additions and insisted on something that is distinct from the original building, which is what they got.

apis ,

Because though uPVC windows lack the myriad advantages of wood or stone frames, sometimes it is better for the ongoing fabric of a building to just get it weatherproof until someone comes along who can afford to put in more suitable replacements.

Then white uPVC frames are much cheaper than coloured versions.

Can't speak for the baby blue.

MethodicalSpark ,

This has been floating around the internet for some time.

The funny part is that heritage zoning is the reason the addition looks the way it does. The upper floor was inaccessible and stairs needed to be added. Local regulations state that any additions must be visually distinct from the original structure so this monstrosity was the result.

Look up Caldwell Tower in Scotland for more information.

someguy3 , (edited )

Why the fuck would additions need to be visually distinct?

Rozz ,

Maybe to not be misleading about what is original and what is new

someguy3 ,

I think you could tell when it goes from stone to plastic.

SturgiesYrFase ,
@SturgiesYrFase@lemmy.ml avatar

I work in stone conservation and for the body that dictates these regulations, even if it was built out of stone it would be required to be visually distinct. The only exception is if it were reinstatement of an original feature that had been demolished or decayed to the point that it had to be removed and fully rebuilt. In that case every effort should be made to source the stone from the same quarry, and the same mortar mix should be used.

someguy3 ,

That's not what I meant.

SturgiesYrFase ,
@SturgiesYrFase@lemmy.ml avatar

Then....what did you mean?

someguy3 ,

Even if it went from grey stone to grey plastic siding, you could tell when it goes from stone to plastic. That should be enough to meet their "different" criteria, but not be such an outrageous eyesore.

BakerBagel ,

An easy way to do that is make the addition not flush, or use a different kind if masonry. The linked documentary includes an interview with the local planning council who recommended finding a local architect with expirience to do it.

Instead the chrap English bastard just used the cheapest options he could find in Essex and wore the council down to approve this monstrosity.

mojofrododojo ,

I'd call this 'malicious compliance'.

Steve ,

I cant understand why that would be a bad thing

Successful_Try543 ,

Maybe, in case the next renovation is due, you know for sure which parts are to be preserved and which can be removed. However, some craftsman or architect doing that should be able to tell the difference between modern boards and windows and ancient ones without relying on the help of white plastics or baby blue paint.

BowtiesAreCool ,

If it’s privately owned, who cares?

Emperor ,
@Emperor@feddit.uk avatar

Here is the episode of The Restoration Man that documented the project - they go into the planning side of this in-depth because it's really a head-scratcher. The owner tried many times to get planning for more subtle alternations but they kept getting knocked back because it has to be distinctive enough that it's clear what is the old building and what are the new additions. What you see is the result of that messy process.

SupraMario ,

That's dumb as fuck, literally even if it was brick you'd be able to tell from the weathering of the original stone. NIMBYs are fucking idiots.

Swedneck ,
@Swedneck@discuss.tchncs.de avatar

if it's so important that we must be able to tell when it was built, just fucking carve the date into each brick lmao

Damage ,

Feels like the owner had enemies in the local administration

Maggoty ,

I'm going to go with the idea they didn't want anyone living in the tower in the first place. So they decided to refuse anything until it was too obvious to deny.

LemmyKnowsBest ,

Local regulations: "any additions must be visually distinct from the original structure."

Castle owner: "ok. So we'll glue my grandma's blue-siding house to the castle."

Local regulations: " No, not like THAAAAT"

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • [email protected]
  • kbinchat
  • All magazines