mastodon.sdf.org

bamboo , to Technology in NetBSD bans all commits of AI-generated code

I can understand why a project might want to do this until the law is fully implemented and testing in court, but I can tell most of the people in this thread haven’t actually figured out how to effectively use LLMs productively. They’re not about to replace software engineers, but as a software engineer, tools like GitHub copilot and ChatGPT are excellent at speeding up a workflow. ChatGPT for example is an excellent search engine that can give you a quick understanding of a topic. It’ll generate small amounts of code more quickly than I could write it by hand. Of course I’m still going to review that code to ensure it is to the same quality that hand written code would be, but overall this is still a much faster problem.

The luddites who hate on LLMs would have complained about the first compilers too, because they could write marginally faster assembly by hand.

Tja ,

Same for intellisense, IDEs, Debuggers, linters, static analyzers, dynamic languages, garbage collection, NoSQL databases...

Anti_Iridium ,

Why use a computer to do the work when I could do myself? /s

mPony , to Technology in Slack is now using all content, including DMs, to train LLMs

The headline is patently false.

FTA

We do not develop LLMs or other generative models using customer data.

If you want to act like you're better than Reddit you're going to have to start actually being better.

diffusive , to Technology in NetBSD bans all commits of AI-generated code

I never felt so close to try NetBSD as after reading this 😃

0x0 , to Technology in Slack is now using all content, including DMs, to train LLMs

mattermost anyone?

possiblylinux127 ,
@possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip avatar

Its used by NASA and the US Air Force so security wise it probably is pretty solid.

Croquette ,

An issue with mattermost is that some useful features are behind a paywall, like group calls.

I'd go with nextcloud since all their features are included regardless of if you pay or not

0x0 ,

Ain't everything open-souce?

Croquette ,

Open-source does not equal free. There is probably a way to circumvent their paywall, but on their website, self-hosted free version has a limit of 1-on-1 for calls.

If you want a group call, you need to pay, even if you self-host.

me_jumper ,

Wait, which calls do you mean? We're hosting or own free mattermost and I've never had that problem.
We're pretty happy with mattermost overall, but it's also a small tech-savvy team.

hperrin , to Technology in NetBSD bans all commits of AI-generated code

Hell yeah! Get that shit… OUTTA HERE!!!

Ok but seriously, that is a very good reason to ban it. Who knows what would happen if the AI just fully ripped someone else’s code off that’s supposed to be like GPL licensed or something. If humans can plagiarize, than AIs can plagiarize.

But also, how are they still using CVS? CVS is so slow and so bad. Even Subversion would be an upgrade.

possiblylinux127 , to Technology in NetBSD bans all commits of AI-generated code
@possiblylinux127@lemmy.zip avatar

We need to see more of this

OozingPositron , to Technology in Slack is now using all content, including DMs, to train LLMs
@OozingPositron@feddit.cl avatar

Some model is going to be trained on my Slaude smut lol.

ConfusedPossum , to Technology in Slack is now using all content, including DMs, to train LLMs

I use Slack at work everyday. I suppose this does feel off in some way but I'm not sure I'm the right amount of upset about this? I don't really mind if they use my data if it improves my user experience, as long as the platform doesn't reveal anything sensitive or personal in a way that can be traced back to me.

Slack already does allow your admin to view all of your conversations, which is more alarming to me

SeedyOne ,

The problem is where you said "as long as" because we already know companies AND the AI itself can't be trusted to not expose sensitive info inadvertently. At absolute best, it's another vector to be breached.

ConfusedPossum ,

It's obvious when you say it like that. I don't like the idea of some prompt hacker looking at memes I sent to my coworker

Blueshift ,

Slack already does allow your admin to view all of your conversations, which is more alarming to me

I’m a slack admin for my company, and I can tell you that no: admins can’t read DMs or private channels they’re not a part of

moon , to Technology in NetBSD bans all commits of AI-generated code

I get banning for quality, but for potential copyright is pretty stupid.

Spedwell ,

It's not really stupid at all. See the matrix code example from this article: https://spectrum.ieee.org/ai-code-generation-ownership

You can't really know when the genAI is synthesizing from thousands of inputs or just outright reciting copyrighted code. Not kosher if it's the latter.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • kbinchat
  • All magazines